| Reality Check! Pundits flapping for a Palestinian Gandhi should meet Khader Adnan!

Pundits Waiting for a Palestinian Gandhi? Meet Khader Adnan ~ Peter Hart

For years prominent corporate media pundits have told us that the world — and the media — would embrace a dramatic, non-violent Palestinian resistance movement. If only such a movement — perhaps led by a Gandhi-like figure — were to finally emerge, we are told, the media coverage will come, and sympathy from across the world will strengthen support for the Palestinian cause.

This is nonsense — there has been non-violent Palestinian resistance for years. But that fact hasn’t stopped pundits like Time‘s Joe Klein, as recentlyas last year, from wondering why Palestinians haven’t found their Gandhi. Or New York Times columnist Tom Friedman from writing a column (5/24/11) arguing that if Palestinians would simply adopt peaceful resistance, “it would become a global news event. Every network in the world would be there.”

Or consider New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof, writing (7/10/10) under the headline “Waiting for Gandhi,” that if Palestinians would finally pursue nonviolent resistance, “Those images would be on televisions around the world.”

“So far there is no Palestinian version of Martin Luther King Jr.,” Kristof wrote — though he singled out one possible candidate, activist Ayed Morrar, who “spent six years in Israeli prisons but seems devoid of bitterness.”

Perhaps that is the standard — jailed by the Israelis, but not bitter.

But what about someone, right now, resisting Israeli detention practices? Someone whose hunger strike is attracting attention around the world? That is Khader Adnan. As Ali Abunimah tells his story:

The 33-year-old Palestinian baker, husband, father and graduate student has refused food since December 18, a day after he was arrested in a nighttime raid on his family home by Israeli occupation forces in the West Bank. He has lost over 40 kgs and his wife Randa and young daughters have described his appearance as “shocking.”Adnan, whom Israel says is a member of Islamic Jihad, was given a four-month “administrative detention” order by the Israeli military — meaning that he is held without being charged for any crime or trial, a practice continued by Israel that dates back to British colonial days.

Yesterday an Israeli military court rejected Adnan’s appeal against the arbitrary detention. Having vowed to maintain his hunger strike until he is released or charged, the judge — an Israeli military officer — might as well have sentenced Khader Adnan to death, unless there is urgent international intervention.

Though the life in his body hangs on by a thread, his spirit is unbroken.

The pundits who tell us that they crave a dramatic nonviolent Palestinian narrative can write the story of Khader Adnan, who has drawncomparisons to celebrated Irish hunger striker Bobby Sands.

But they are not writing his story. His plight is sparsely covered in the U.S. corporate media, and would seem to go unmentioned by these pundits who seem eager to tell stories like his.

It might lead one to believe that Friedman and his ilk don’t really mean what they write.


2 thoughts on “| Reality Check! Pundits flapping for a Palestinian Gandhi should meet Khader Adnan!

  1. Their excuse is fatuous. They need no such symbolic hero to write of their support of the Israeli State. Where is Israel’s Ghandi? Can they point to one?

    There are many opportunities for these experienced and informed professional writers to create a suitable human focus for a story of the Palestinian struggle. Choose a story from the thousands of people who’ve had land stolen and uprooted, lost homes, son’s and daughters have been killed, and yet have not struck back; from the writers and academics and professionals who struggle to advance the cause of Palestine. What are they waiting for, a message for God? I suggest God is crying to them out at their malevolance, but onto deaf ears.


  2. Pingback: Bobby Sands’ spokesman, close friend calls on Israel to immediately release Khader Adnan « seachranaidhe1

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.